North Carolina Appellate Attorney
A trial court decision can have lasting consequences for your family, your finances, your business, or your legal rights. But when you believe an important legal error has been made, the entry of an order or judgment does not always mean the matter is over.
You may have the right to appeal.
At Myers Law Firm, we help clients evaluate adverse decisions and determine whether an appeal provides a realistic path forward. Our attorneys draw on decades of litigation experience to identify appealable issues, develop focused legal arguments, prepare appellate briefs, and advocate for clients throughout the appellate process.
If you recently received an unfavorable court ruling, don’t wait to seek legal advice. Appellate deadlines can begin running immediately after an order or judgment is entered or served.
What Does a North Carolina Appellate Attorney Do?
An appellate attorney represents clients who are challenging a lower court decision or defending a favorable decision that another party has appealed.
This work differs from trial litigation.
At trial, attorneys build a factual record through testimony, documents, exhibits, and other evidence. At the appellate level, the record has generally already been created. The appellate lawyer must determine what legal issues were properly preserved, what evidence and rulings are part of the record, what standard the appellate judges will use to review each issue, and which arguments offer the strongest basis for relief.
Just as importantly, an appellate lawyer should give you a realistic assessment of your case. Not every disappointing result involves an appealable error, and not every legal error justifies reversal. Effective appellate representation begins with identifying the issues that matter most.
How Does the North Carolina Court of Appeals Work?
The North Carolina Court of Appeals is the state’s intermediate appellate court. It has 15 judges, and most cases are considered by panels of three judges.
The Court of Appeals does not conduct another trial, but reviews proceedings from lower courts for errors of law or legal procedure. Its role is generally to determine whether the trial court applied the law correctly and whether a prejudicial legal error occurred.
If you disagree with a judge’s decision simply because you think the evidence should have been viewed differently, that does not necessarily constitute a successful appeal.
Appellate courts often place significant weight on certain factual findings or discretionary decisions. Some issues, particularly questions about the proper interpretation or application of law, may receive a different and potentially less deferential type of review.
One of an appellate lawyer’s most important jobs is determining exactly what the Court of Appeals is permitted to review and framing the argument accordingly.
What Types of Cases Can Be Appealed in North Carolina?
Most appeals from North Carolina Superior and District Courts proceed to the North Carolina Court of Appeals, although exceptions exist.
For Myers Law Firm clients, appellate issues may arise in several areas.
Family Law Appeals
Family law orders can profoundly affect parents, children, property division, and finances for years. Depending on the type and finality of the order, appeals may arise from decisions involving:
- Child custody
- Child support
- Alimony or post-separation support
- Equitable distribution
- Contempt
- Domestic violence protective orders
- Other family law matters
Family law appeals can be especially complicated because trial judges often have discretion when making certain decisions. A successful appeal generally requires more than showing that another judge could have reached a different result. The issue may fall more on whether the court applied the wrong legal standard, failed to make legally required findings, made findings unsupported by the applicable record, or otherwise committed reversible error.
Civil Litigation Appeals
Civil appeals may arise from contract disputes, real estate litigation, business disputes, personal injury lawsuits, and many other civil cases.
Potential appellate issues can involve:
- Dismissal of a claim
- Summary judgment
- Interpretation of a contract or statute
- Admission or exclusion of evidence
- Jury instructions
- Post-trial motions
- Damages
- Jurisdiction
- Procedural rulings
Whether a particular ruling can be appealed immediately depends on both the nature of the ruling and where the case stands procedurally.
Hear From Our Clients
“I wanted to thank you. I know it takes a lot to put together a case. After the first time meeting with you, you remembered our information, barely referring to your notes and continued to do so. You were generous with your thoughts and ideas as to how we could get what we were hoping for and it's so appreciated. We couldn't have gotten the verdict yesterday without you....It really does make a difference that you seem to care.”
“I went to another law firm and they turned me down…would not take my case. Myers Law Firm met with me, handled my case and would not back down from insurance company. Even when they had to file suit to protect me for my personal injury and property damage. I received a very fair settlement. Mr. Myers I appreciate you and your staff.”
“Mr. Lee-Thanks to you and Bessie for all of your help last year and most recently with the referral. I sold the house and the kids and I moved 8 days before Christmas. God is good, faithful and true.”
Want to learn more about personal injury cases?
We’ll send you a series of free informational emails starting today.
Final Orders and Interlocutory Appeals
One of the first questions an appellate lawyer must answer is whether the decision can be appealed now.
Appeals From Final Judgments
A final judgment generally resolves the case or all remaining claims between the parties. In many civil cases, a party who is legally aggrieved by a final judgment has a right to appeal.
The precise deadline and procedure still matter. Missing the deadline for a notice of appeal can jeopardize the right to appellate review.
Interlocutory Appeals
An interlocutory order is entered before the entire case has been concluded.
North Carolina generally limits immediate appeals from interlocutory orders. However, state law allows some interlocutory appeals when an order affects a “substantial right” or fits another recognized basis for immediate appellate review.
Determining whether a substantial right is affected can be legally complex. Filing an improper interlocutory appeal can create delay and other problems, while failing to appeal an immediately appealable order may also have consequences. Advice from an appellate attorney can be especially valuable.
Petitions for Writ of Certiorari
There are circumstances where a party does not have an ordinary appeal of right or may have lost the right to appeal through the normal procedure.
Rule 21 of the North Carolina Rules of Appellate Procedure permits a party in certain circumstances to ask an appellate court to review a lower court decision through a petition for writ of certiorari.
Certiorari is discretionary. Filing a petition doesn’t mean the appellate court must accept the case. An appellate attorney can evaluate whether this form of review may be appropriate.
What Is the North Carolina Appeals Process?
The exact procedure depends on the type of case, but a typical civil appeal includes several important stages.
1. Determine Whether You Can Appeal
Before filing anything, your attorney should analyze the judgment or order and determine whether you have a right to appeal, whether the decision is final or interlocutory, what issues may be reviewed, and when the deadline expires.
In many North Carolina civil cases, a notice of appeal must be filed and served within 30 days. However, exactly when that period begins can depend on when the judgment was entered and served and whether certain timely post-trial motions were filed.
2. File the Notice of Appeal
The notice of appeal begins the formal appellate process. It is generally filed with the clerk of the trial court rather than initially with the Court of Appeals.
The notice must properly identify the party taking the appeal and the order or judgment being challenged.
3. Obtain the Transcript and Build the Record on Appeal
The appellate judges need a record showing what happened in the trial court. Depending on the case, that may include pleadings, motions, orders, exhibits, relevant transcripts, and other materials necessary to understand the appellate issues.
Under the current appellate rules, there are specific deadlines governing transcript arrangements and preparation and settlement of the record.
4. Identify and Refine the Strongest Issues
Not every possible complaint belongs in an appellate brief. Trying to appeal every unfavorable ruling can make a brief less persuasive by distracting attention from the strongest legal errors.
An appellate attorney reviews what happened in the lower court, determines which issues were properly preserved, identifies the applicable standard of review, researches relevant precedent, and focuses the appeal on arguments most likely to matter to the judges.
Written Briefs Are Central to an Appeal
After the record is filed, the parties submit written appellate briefs.
The appellant’s brief explains what the lower court did, identifies the claimed errors, cites the record, discusses relevant statutes and appellate decisions, and explains what remedy the appellate court should provide.
The appellee then submits a brief defending the result or responding to the appellant’s arguments. The appellant may also have an opportunity to file a reply brief.
North Carolina’s appellate rules establish detailed requirements for the organization, formatting, content, citations, and timing of briefs. At Myers Law Firm, we work to meet these requirements in a clear, focused, and persuasive manner.
Will There Be Oral Argument?
Sometimes.
North Carolina Court of Appeals cases are ordinarily assigned to a three-judge panel, but not every appeal receives oral argument. The court can decide a case based entirely on the record and written briefs.
When oral argument is held, appellate lawyers must be prepared to answer questions from the judges, address weaknesses in their position, distinguish unfavorable cases, and explain why the requested result follows from the law.
Effective appellate advocacy therefore requires preparation for both written and oral presentation.
What Can Happen If You Win an Appeal?
“Winning” an appeal can mean different things depending on the error involved.
An appellate court may reverse a lower court ruling, vacate an order, send the case back to the trial court for additional findings or proceedings, order a new trial, or provide other appropriate relief.
In some cases, an appellate victory doesn’t end the underlying dispute. The matter may return to the trial court for further proceedings under instructions from the appellate court.
Talk to a North Carolina Appellate Attorney at Myers Law Firm
If you believe a North Carolina court made a legal error in your case—or another party is challenging a decision you won—the appellate process can determine whether that ruling remains in place.
Myers Law Firm helps clients evaluate appeals arising from family law, civil litigation, and other matters within our practice. We combine careful legal analysis with the personalized attention our clients expect from our Charlotte firm.
Contact Myers Law Firm at 888-376-2889 or fill out our online form to request a consultation. Bring the judgment or order you want reviewed, along with any information you have about when it was entered and served. The sooner we can evaluate the ruling, the more opportunity we have to protect important appellate rights.
Frequently Asked Questions About North Carolina Appeals
How long do I have to appeal a civil case in North Carolina?
In many civil cases, North Carolina’s Rules of Appellate Procedure provide a 30-day period for filing and serving a notice of appeal. The precise starting point can depend on when the judgment was entered and served, and certain timely post-trial motions can affect the timeline. Some proceedings also have different or expedited rules.
Because missing an appellate deadline can be fatal to an appeal, contact an attorney promptly after receiving an unfavorable order rather than calculating the deadline on your own.
Can I introduce new evidence during my appeal?
Usually not. The North Carolina Court of Appeals reviews what occurred in the lower court and generally bases its decision on the established appellate record. It is not another trial where the parties can call new witnesses simply because they believe different evidence would produce a better result.
Can I appeal a temporary or non-final order?
Sometimes, but not every interlocutory order can be appealed immediately. North Carolina law permits immediate review of certain orders that affect a substantial right or otherwise meet statutory requirements. Whether an order qualifies can involve a detailed legal analysis.
An appellate attorney can review the order and determine whether immediate appeal is available or whether the issue should be preserved until a final judgment.
Do I need a different attorney for an appeal?
You are not necessarily required to change lawyers, but appellate advocacy requires a different set of skills from trial work. Appeals rely heavily on legal research, issue preservation, standards of review, record preparation, and written briefing. An appellate attorney can either take over the appeal or, depending on the case, work with trial counsel to identify and present the strongest issues.
Does filing an appeal automatically stop the trial court’s order?
Not always. A party may need to request a stay or take other steps to prevent enforcement of a civil judgment or order while an appeal is pending. The procedure depends on the type of case and ruling involved. If you are concerned that an order will be enforced before the Court of Appeals can review it, speak with an attorney immediately.
How long does an appeal take?
There is no single timeline. Preparing transcripts and the record, filing briefs, calendaring the case, possible oral argument, and waiting for an opinion can take months or longer. More complicated appeals may take additional time, particularly if extensions, special motions, rehearing, or Supreme Court review become involved.
Your appellate attorney should keep you informed about the major deadlines and procedural stages as the case moves forward.
What happens if the other side appeals a case that I won?
You may need an appellate attorney even when you are not the party seeking review. As the appellee, your job is generally to defend the lower court’s result and respond to the errors alleged by the appellant. In some circumstances, an appellee may also need to preserve alternative legal grounds or pursue a cross-appeal. Early review allows your lawyer to develop a strategy before briefing deadlines begin to arrive.
Can You Appeal from the Court of Appeals to the North Carolina Supreme Court?
Sometimes, but Supreme Court review is more limited.
North Carolina law provides an appeal of right from a Court of Appeals decision in certain cases involving a substantial constitutional question. In many other cases, a party must ask the Supreme Court to accept the case through discretionary review.
The fact that you lost in the Court of Appeals does not automatically entitle you to another appeal. Myers Law Firm can evaluate whether further review may be available and worthwhile.
Contact Myers Law Firm
We are committed to continuing to serve our clients’ legal needs
Single Divider
Please don’t hesitate to reach out for a consultation to discuss how we can help you. We are happy to meet with you in-person, over the telephone, or via video conference to discuss your situation, your needs, and how our attorneys can help.